Toronto FCNew York Red Bulls
- 1Sean Johnson
- 27Shane O'Neill
- 5Kevin Long
- 28Raoul Petretta
- 22Richie Laryea
- 16Tyrese Spicer
- 21Jonathan Osorio
- 20Deybi Flores
- 10Federico Bernardeschi
- 11Derrick Etienne
- 29Deandre Kerr
- 1Carlos Miguel
- 12Dylan Nealis
- 4Andres Reyes
- 3Noah Eile
- 47John Tolkin
- 5Peter Stroud
- 48Ronald Donkor
- 75Daniel Edelman
- 10Emil Forsberg
- 13Dante Vanzeir
- 9Lewis Morgan
